Back to Articles

GST section 74 notice: the fraud must be on its face, CBIC now says

By CA Karan Gupta

finance
19/11/2026
GST section 74 notice: the fraud must be on its face, CBIC now says featured image

CBIC Circular 258/04/2026-GST of 26 October 2026 tells GST officers that a notice under section 74, or section 74A(5)(ii), must set out on its face the specific facts that show fraud, wilful

Summary

CBIC Circular 258/04/2026-GST of 26 October 2026 tells GST officers that a notice under section 74, or section 74A(5)(ii), must set out on its face the specific facts that show fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax, and that these provisions cannot be used merely because tax is unpaid or a scrutiny found a mismatch. It rests on the Supreme Court's ruling in G.R. Infra Projects (19 August 2026) that a defect in the notice cannot be cured later, so the face of the notice is the first thing to test in any reply.

The situation

Section 73 cases for FY 2022-23 ran out of notice time on 30 September 2026. Section 74 still has years to run. So an officer who finds an old mismatch now has one route left: call it suppression.

Many of the notices that do this read the same way. The facts are a GSTR-2A or GSTR-3B difference, and the closing paragraph adds "fraud or wilful misstatement or suppression of facts" with nothing to support it. Until now the answer was a list of High Court rulings. Since 26 October it is also the department's own instruction to its officers.

The rule

Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST ("Clarification on issues related to demand, adjudication and appeal proceedings under the CGST Act, 2017", 26.10.2026) is issued under section 168(1) of the CGST Act. The paragraphs that matter for a section 74 notice:

ParaWhat it says
4.4Quoting G.R. Infra Projects Ltd v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2026) 45 Centax 331 (SC), 19.08.2026: what a notice needs to be valid "must be contained therein", and a deficiency "cannot subsequently be cured or remedied".
5.1The notice "should specifically disclose the basis" for invoking fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression. Mechanical reproduction of the words "would not suffice". It quotes para 10 of G.R. Infra: the allegations "should emanate from the notice itself".
5.2Intent to evade is part of all three. Where facts are known to both parties, an omission by one is not suppression. An incorrect statement is not a wilful misstatement unless made knowing it is false (Sriba Nirman Company, AP HC, (2025) 29 Centax 206, said to be affirmed by the Supreme Court).
5.3Section 74(1) or 74A(5)(ii) "cannot be invoked merely on the ground of non‑payment of GST", and is "not intended to be applied in scrutiny cases solely because a discrepancy has been noticed".
5.5A second notice on the same facts for a later period, again alleging fraud, is "generally not legally valid" unless there are new and independent grounds.
6A notice that proposes demands under both sections 73 and 74 must give reasons for the split and quantify each part separately.
13If the notice lacks clear evidence of intent, the adjudicating authority should confine the demand to section 73 or 74A(5)(i).

Other parts of the circular cover personal hearings, with at most four opportunities (para 10.1(i), read with section 75(5)), and the rule that an order cannot go beyond the grounds in the notice (para 11.6, section 75(7)). Para 11.7.1 says any use of AI in drafting an order needs human oversight.

Where people go wrong

Replying on the merits first. If the notice does not say why the officer infers fraud, that is a defect in the notice itself. Under para 4.4 and G.R. Infra it cannot be fixed at the hearing or in the order. Put it first in the reply, before the merits.

Reading "limitation decided first" as a rule about notices. Some summaries of this circular say limitation is now decided first. Para 15.2 says that about the limitation of the appeal: the first appellate authority must decide whether the appeal was filed in time as a preliminary issue. It is not a rule about when a notice was issued. The notice-date test for section 73 is still the statute's own (section 73(2) and 73(10)).

Citing the circular back to the officer and expecting a dropped notice. Para 17 says the guidelines are illustrative and "must not be cited by proper officers" in notices or orders. They bind officers on how to act. They do not make any notice void automatically. Use them alongside G.R. Infra and the High Court rulings, not instead of them.

Missing the mixed notice. A notice that puts one set of facts under section 73 and another under section 74, without separate figures for each, breaks para 6. For FY 2022-23, the section 73 part may also be out of time. See my earlier piece on the 30 September 2026 cut-off.

Treating section 74A like section 74. For FY 2024-25 onwards, section 74A has a single 42-month notice period for both fraud and non-fraud cases (para 6). The fraud label there changes the penalty, not the time limit. The face-of-the-notice test in para 5.1 applies to section 74A(5)(ii) too.

What to do

  1. Read every section 74 or 74A(5)(ii) notice for the specific facts it gives to support fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression, and list them.
  2. Make "no specific allegation of intent on the face of the notice" the first ground of the reply where that list is empty, citing G.R. Infra and Circular 258/04/2026-GST paras 4.4, 5.1 and 5.3.
  3. Check whether the facts were already in your client's returns or the department's records, and if so say so: an omission of facts known to both sides is not suppression (para 5.2).
  4. Ask, in writing, for a split with separate quantification if the notice mixes sections 73 and 74.
  5. Keep a record of each hearing date and adjournment, to hold the department to the four-hearing limit and to the grounds in the notice.

The tool

I have not built a tool that reads a notice, and I won't: whether a notice discloses intent is a reading of its facts, and that is your job and mine, not a calculator's. What I kept re-deriving was what follows an order: the appeal clock, the pre-deposit and a frozen bank account. That is my GST appeal-route tool. Its next version fixes a pre-deposit figure, so I have not linked it here. It does not read your notice and does not decide whether section 74 was rightly invoked. Read the circular itself, and verify your reply with your CA.

Sources

  1. CBIC Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST, 26 October 2026 (copy hosted by CAalley): https://www.caalley.com/gst26/Circular-No-258-04-2026.pdf
  2. Supreme Court, G.R. Infra Projects Ltd v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (2026) 45 Centax 331 (SC), 19 August 2026, as quoted in the circular
  3. CGST Act, 2017, sections 73, 74, 74A and 75, on the CBIC GST portal: https://cbic-gst.gov.in/gst-acts.html
  4. CAalley, list of the eight GST circulars dated 26 October 2026: https://caalley.com/tax-laws-updates/8-gst-circulars-dated-october-26-2026

Share line (for WhatsApp / LinkedIn — Karan pastes it once the article is live)

CBIC Circular 258: a GST s.74 notice must state on its face the facts showing intent to evade. A mismatch or unpaid tax alone is not enough. the related note