Back to Articles

Exported without an LUT? The refund is not lost, but the proof is yours

By CA Karan Gupta

finance
19/11/2026
Exported without an LUT? The refund is not lost, but the proof is yours featured image

An export made without a Letter of Undertaking (LUT) and without paying IGST is still a zero-rated export: CBIC's own circular says the delay in filing the LUT "may be condoned" and the LUT accepted

Summary

An export made without a Letter of Undertaking (LUT) and without paying IGST is still a zero-rated export: CBIC's own circular says the delay in filing the LUT "may be condoned" and the LUT accepted after the event, where the export itself is established. The fight is over proof of export, not over the missing form, and High Courts in 2025–26 have sent refund rejections back on exactly this ground (reported).

The situation

A software developer in Bhilai invoices a client in Singapore every month. The invoices carry no IGST, the dollars arrive, the bank issues remittance advices. Nobody filed the LUT for the year. When the refund claim for the unused input credit goes in, the officer rejects it in one line: no LUT, so the supply is not zero-rated; pay IGST with interest and claim it back.

That is the question on a CAclubindia thread first asked in February 2024 and answered again on 31 October 2026. The replies still disagree. One says pay and reclaim. One says the export is simply not zero-rated. One cites a CBDT circular, which is an income-tax body and has nothing to say about GST. Only the last one names the CBIC circular that answers it.

The rule

What the law asks for. An exporter may supply goods or services without paying integrated tax after furnishing a bond or LUT (rule 96A(1) of the CGST Rules, read with section 16(3) of the IGST Act). The LUT is filed online in Form GST RFD-11 for a financial year.

What CBIC said about a missing LUT. Circular No. 37/11/2018-GST of 15 March 2018, para 4, records that "in some cases, such zero rated supplies have been made before filing the LUT and refund claims for unutilized input tax credit have been filed". Para 4.1 then says:

> "the substantive benefits of zero rating may not be denied where it has been established that exports in terms of the relevant provisions have been made. The delay in furnishing of LUT in such cases may be condoned and the facility for export under LUT may be allowed on ex post facto basis taking into account the facts and circumstances of each case."

Para 15 applies the instructions to exports from 1 July 2017 and adds that refunds "may not be withheld due to minor procedural lapses or non-substantive errors or omission". Para 5.1 takes the same line on goods exported after the three-month period.

Where that text sits today. CBIC's master refund circular, No. 125/44/2019-GST of 18 November 2019, rescinded the older refund circulars and is reported to carry the same condonation in its para 44. Cite both: 125/2019 as the current text, 37/2018 as the origin.

What the courts have done (reported).

CourtCaseDateOutcome
Delhi HCAlkesh Tacker HUFSep 2025Missing LUT treated as procedural
Karnataka HCPrime Perfumery Works (W.P. 11076/2024)2 Dec 2025Refund rejected solely for no LUT; remitted for fresh decision
Karnataka HCNuvteq Solutions (W.P. 16115/2026)10 Jun 2026No demand on an export of services merely because there was no LUT

No ruling upholding a rejection for want of an LUT alone was found.

Where people go wrong

Arguing about the form instead of the export. The circular protects the exporter "where it has been established that exports ... have been made". For services, that means meeting the definition of export of services in section 2(6) of the IGST Act, including payment received in convertible foreign exchange (or rupees where RBI allows). For goods, the shipping bill and export general manifest. A file that proves the export wins the LUT point. A file that does not will lose on something else.

Paying IGST with interest "to be safe". It is the officer's suggestion, and it is expensive: the cash is locked until a second refund comes through, and the interest is gone. The circular exists so that this is not the default. Pay only where you choose to, and say in writing that it is under protest.

Believing the LUT "cannot be filed after April". An LUT can be furnished during the year. What it cannot do on its own is cover exports already made before it. Those need the condonation in para 4.1, which is a request to the jurisdictional Commissioner, not a backdated portal filing.

Citing the wrong authority. A CBDT circular has no force in GST. Neither does a forum reply. Quote the CBIC circulars by number and paragraph, and the High Court cases with their writ numbers.

Ignoring the refund clock. Condonation fixes the LUT. It does not extend the two-year limit for the refund itself under section 54(1) of the CGST Act. Work out the relevant date for each period before you spend months on the LUT argument.

What to do

  1. File the LUT for FY 2026-27 in RFD-11 today, if it is not on the portal, so that the problem stops growing.
  2. Put together the export proof for every affected invoice: invoice, contract or purchase order, foreign inward remittance advice or BRC for services, shipping bill for goods.
  3. Write to the jurisdictional Commissioner asking for ex post facto acceptance of the LUT for the past period, quoting para 4.1 of Circular 37/11/2018-GST and para 44 of Circular 125/44/2019-GST.
  4. In any reply to a deficiency memo, show cause notice or rejection order, rest the case on proof of export and cite the circulars and the High Court cases.
  5. Check the two-year refund limit for each period, and file or appeal within it.

The tool

I have built tools around export rules, but not for this one. My export-realisation tool works out the FEMA deadline for receiving export proceeds, which is a different law and a different clock, and the version on my tools page is waiting for a correction, so I am not linking it here. Nothing I publish files an LUT or a refund, and nothing I publish can tell whether your documents prove an export. The two circulars and the case table above are the working file; verify the position with your CA before writing to the department.

Sources

  1. CBIC Circular No. 37/11/2018-GST, 15 March 2018, paras 4, 4.1, 5.1 and 15: https://gstcouncil.gov.in/sites/default/files/2024-06/circularno-37-cgst.pdf
  2. CBIC Circular No. 125/44/2019-GST, 18 November 2019 (master refund circular): https://gstcouncil.gov.in/sites/default/files/2024-06/circular-cgst-125.pdf
  3. CGST Rules, 2017, rule 96A; CGST Act, 2017, section 54; IGST Act, 2017, sections 2(6) and 16: https://cbic-gst.gov.in/gst-acts.html
  4. Masters India, on refunds where the LUT was filed after export (case summaries): https://www.mastersindia.co/blog/gst-refund-rejection-can-you-file-lut-after-export/
  5. Jurishour, on non-filing of LUT and zero-rated status: https://www.jurishour.in/gst/non-filing-of-lut-zero-rated-supply-status/
  6. CAclubindia forum thread, "GST refund denied due to non-filing of LUT": https://www.caclubindia.com/forum/gst-refund-denied-due-to-non-filing-of-lut-605458.asp

Share line (for WhatsApp / LinkedIn — Karan pastes it once the article is live)

Exported without an LUT? CBIC says the delay may be condoned and the LUT accepted after the event, if the export is proved (Circ. 37/2018 para 4.1). the related note