Back to Articles

Rule 46(8): your books may sit abroad, the daily backup may not

By CA Karan Gupta

accounting
4/11/2026
Rule 46(8): your books may sit abroad, the daily backup may not featured image

Since 1 April 2026, Rule 46(8) of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 has required books kept electronically to stay accessible in India at all times and to be backed up every day on servers physically

Summary

Since 1 April 2026, Rule 46(8) of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 has required books kept electronically to stay accessible in India at all times and to be backed up every day on servers physically located in India; it does not require the live system to be in India. From tax year 2026-27 the tax auditor reports the accounting software, the server's IP address and country, and the address of the India backup server in Form No. 26, so the gap has to be closed by 31 March 2027, not at the audit.

The situation

Two opposite things are being published about this rule. A long line of advisories tells businesses that their books "must be on an Indian server" and that cloud accounting hosted abroad has to move. At least one practising CA has published the reverse: that the Rules contain no such requirement and that the profession has confused it with a Companies Act rule. A client on a Singapore-hosted ERP reads both and asks what to do. His auditor, meanwhile, will have to sign four facts about the client's servers that no auditor can know first-hand, and there is no working paper anywhere for obtaining them. Both camps are wrong, and the answer sits in one sentence of the rule.

The rule

Rule 46(8), made under section 62 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the successor to s.44AA of the 1961 Act) and notified in the Income-tax Rules, 2026 by Notification 22/2026, G.S.R. 198(E), dated 20 March 2026, in force 1 April 2026, reads in the published text of the Rules:

> "The books of account and other documents specified in sub-rules (1), (4) and (6) maintained in > electronic mode shall remain accessible in India at all times, and the backup of such books of > account and other documents maintained in electronic mode, shall be kept on a daily basis in servers > physically located in India."

Two duties, then: the books must be accessible in India at all times, and a daily backup must sit on servers physically in India. Nothing requires the primary system to be in India. Sub-rules (1), (4) and (6) cover every person required to keep books under s.62, the specified professions, and the medical profession's registers, so the rule is neither companies-only nor professions-only. Rule 46(9) keeps the books, and therefore the backup, for seven tax years from the end of the relevant tax year.

Who keeps books at all (s.62 of the 2025 Act):

PersonBooks required when, in any one of the three preceding tax years
Individual or HUF in business or a non-specified professionIncome above ₹2,50,000 or turnover above ₹25,00,000
Any other person (company, firm, LLP, trust) in business or a non-specified professionIncome above ₹1,20,000 or turnover above ₹10,00,000
Specified profession (now including information technology and company secretaries)Always, except gross receipts not above ₹1,50,000 (Rule 46(3))
Anyone claiming profit below the deemed rate under s.58(2) or s.61(2)Always

Penalty on the assessee: a flat ₹25,000 under s.441 of the 2025 Act for failing to keep or retain books as required, with a reasonable-cause defence under s.470.

The auditor's side. Form No. 26, prescribed by Rule 47 read with s.63 (the old s.44AB), replaces Forms 3CA, 3CB and 3CD from tax year 2026-27; the first report is due 30 September 2027. Where books are kept electronically it asks for the accounting software, the IP address and country of the server holding the accounting data, and the address of the India backup server. This season's AY 2026-27 reports stay on Form 3CD. Separately, s.463 of the 2025 Act (the old s.271J) makes an accountant liable to ₹10,000 for each report or certificate carrying incorrect information, and s.470 lists s.463 among the penalties a reasonable cause defeats.

Companies owe it twice. Rule 3 of the Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, as amended by G.S.R. 624(E) of 5 August 2022 (in force 11 August 2022), already requires a company's electronic books to be accessible in India at all times and their backup, including of books kept outside India, to be kept daily on servers physically in India; Rule 3(6) requires the service provider's name, IP address and location to be intimated to the Registrar every year with the financial statements; and since 1 April 2023 the software must keep an audit trail that cannot be disabled. The officers' exposure is ₹50,000 to ₹5,00,000 under s.128(6) of the Companies Act, 2013.

Where people go wrong

"Move the books to India." The rule localises the backup, not the books. A primary in Frankfurt or Virginia is lawful if the books can be opened from India on demand and a copy lands on an Indian server every day. A migration sold on the strength of this rule is a migration nobody asked for.

"The rule does not exist." The dissent never reproduces the notified text it says lacks the requirement, and it does not deal with Form No. 26 at all. Its real point, that many advisories confuse the income-tax rule with the Companies Act rule, is fair about the advisories and wrong about the Rules. A company owes both.

Calling it "Rule 4A". The Companies Act provision is Rule 3 of the Companies (Accounts) Rules,

  1. A working paper that cites Rule 4A cites something else.

A company below the income-tax thresholds. A dormant or first-year company may fall outside s.62 on its figures, but every company keeps books under s.128 of the Companies Act and owes the Rule 3 backup regardless.

"Daily" read loosely. A weekly job, or a copy taken by hand when someone remembers, is not daily. The safe reading is an automatic job every calendar day with a timestamped log of each run. Whether non-working days must run is unsettled; schedule them and the question disappears.

"The vendor backs it up." Perhaps, but where? A consumer drive whose storage region was never fixed, or a software vendor's backup whose location nobody has confirmed in writing, is an unknown, not a compliance.

Treating ₹10,000 as a server penalty. It is the general penalty for any incorrect report or certificate. What protects the auditor is evidence of a reasonable enquiry: a written request to the client for the four facts, answered and signed.

Waiting for the audit. The obligation has run since 1 April 2026 and a missed day cannot be backfilled. The auditor will report the set-up as it stands, so the last useful day to fix a gap before the first Form No. 26 is 31 March 2027.

What to do

  1. Decide first whether the person keeps books under s.62 at all, and, for a company, remember Rule 3 applies whatever the income-tax answer.
  2. Get from whoever holds the login, in writing: the software, where the live system sits (country and IP address), where the backup lands (the physical address or the cloud provider's Indian region, confirmed by the provider), and how often it runs.
  3. Close any gap now: an automatic daily backup to an Indian server, with a log, and a way to open the books from India whenever asked.
  4. Send each audit client a one-page enquiry for the four Form No. 26 facts before 31 March 2027, and file the signed reply as your reasonable-cause evidence.
  5. For companies, check the AOC-4 intimation under Rule 3(6) and the audit-trail setting in the same exercise.

The tool

When I went through the tax-audit annexures looking for what still had to be done by hand, this was the one no tool covered, so I built a page for it. You answer five questions (which software, where the live books sit, where the backup goes, how often it runs, who keeps the books) and it returns one of five verdicts: your set-up complies, you are one fix away, it does not comply, you cannot say yet, or the rule does not reach you. It keeps "nobody has told you where the backup is" apart from "there is no backup", names each gap with the fix and the person to ask, shows a separate card for a company's Rule 3 duties, and prints a one-page enquiry-and-representation sheet on your letterhead carrying the four Form No. 26 facts with a column for the client to confirm or correct and a signature line. It does not name any vendor or cloud region as compliant, it does not fill Form No. 26 or print a clause number for it, and it does not count past days of non-compliance. For a company typed in below the income-tax thresholds, read the company card rather than the headline verdict; that branch is being corrected. Nothing you type is uploaded.

Open the rule 46 8 page

Sources

  1. Income-tax Rules, 2026, Rule 46 — Notification 22/2026, G.S.R. 198(E), 20 March 2026 (ITD notification page) — https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/w/notification-no.-22/2026-f.-no.-370142/41/2025-tpl-/-g.s.r.-198-e-
  2. Rule 46 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026, published text (ten sub-rules; sub-rules (8) and (9)) — https://www.lawspedia.in/rule-46-of-income-tax-rules-2026
  3. Income-tax Act, 2025, s.62 (books of account; thresholds) — https://eztax.in/income-tax-act-2025/section-62
  4. Income-tax Act, 2025, s.441, s.463 and s.470 — https://eztax.in/income-tax-act-2025/section-441 · https://eztax.in/income-tax-act-2025/section-463 · https://eztax.in/income-tax-act-2025/section-470
  5. Income Tax Department — Form No. 26 — https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/documents/d/guest/fn-26
  6. TaxGuru — Form No. 26 under s.63 and Rule 47 — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/income-tax-form-no-26-audit-report-statement-particulars-required-furnished-section-63.html
  7. SCC Online — Companies (Accounts) Fourth Amendment Rules, 2022 (G.S.R. 624(E)) — https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2022/08/16/record-keeping-requirements-modified-vide-companies-accounts-fourth-amendment-rules-2022/
  8. ICAI Journal — audit trail requirements and responsibilities — https://cajournal.icai.org/article-details/audit-trail-requirements-responsibilities
  9. Tally Solutions — the daily data backup requirement from 1 April 2026 — https://tallysolutions.com/gst/everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-daily-data-backup-requirement-effective-1-april-2026/