Back to Articles

Reassessment with no s.143(2) notice is void: check it before immunity

By CA Karan Gupta

finance
19/11/2026
Reassessment with no s.143(2) notice is void: check it before immunity featured image

The Supreme Court held on 28 October 2026 that a reassessment under s. 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is void if no s.

Summary

The Supreme Court held on 28 October 2026 that a reassessment under s.147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is void if no s.143(2) notice was issued after the return filed in response to the s.148 notice, and that s.292BB does not save it, even where the assessee took part without objecting. Before a client accepts a reassessment order through s.270AA immunity or the Dispute Resolution Committee, check the record for that notice, because both routes give up the appeal in which the ground would win.

The situation

Several lakh reopened assessments for the years before 2021 are working their way to orders and appeals. In many of them the assessee answered the s.148 notice with a letter: "please treat my original return as the return filed in response." The department then issued s.142(1) questionnaires, the assessee replied, and an order followed. Nobody issued a s.143(2) notice, and nobody noticed.

From December to April those orders arrive with a one-month window to apply for immunity. That is the moment a client is most tempted to settle, and the moment this ruling matters most.

The rule

Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Bhubaneswar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd, 2026 INSC 1171, decided on 28 October 2026 by Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva, dismissed the Revenue's appeals. The ITAT had set the reassessment orders aside and the High Court had upheld it.

The facts were ordinary. Returns had been filed and assessed under s.143(3). The cases were reopened under s.147 with s.148 notices. One assessee asked that its original return be treated as filed in response; another refiled the same return. Section 142(1) notices followed and reassessment orders were passed. No s.143(2) notice was ever issued.

The Court held, as reported by LiveLaw (30 October 2026):

QuestionHolding
Is the s.143(2) notice needed in a reassessment?Yes — a "sine qua non for a proceeding for reassessment under Section 147", following Hotel Blue Moon
Is its absence a curable irregularity?No
Does s.292BB cure it if the assessee took part?No. The fiction covers defects in a notice that was issued and served. It "cannot come into play where the Revenue has admittedly not even issued the notice" (following Laxman Das Khandelwal)
Does asking that the original return stand change anything?No. The duty to issue the notice "cannot be dispensed with"
Can a s.142(1) letter stand in for it?No. It "would not validate what is non est"

Old and new numbers. Every reassessment order now on the shelf is a 1961-Act order. Notices for AY 2021-22 to 2025-26 issued after 1 April 2026 still run under the 1961 Act's s.148, saved by s.536(2)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (reported). From tax year 2026-27 the 2025 Act's chapter applies: s.147, s.148 and s.148A are reported to map to s.279, s.280 and s.281. One commentary places the scrutiny-notice step at s.270(8). Whether the ruling carries over, and what replaces s.292BB, has not been read in the enacted text. Treat this article as a 1961-Act article.

Where people go wrong

Thinking participation waived it. The usual reply to the objection is that the assessee filed replies, attended and never complained. The Court held that this does not give the officer jurisdiction, and that s.292BB does not stop the assessee from objecting later. It was enacted to cure service defects, not the absence of a notice.

Thinking "treat my original return as filed" made the notice unnecessary. That letter is a return in response to s.148. The s.143(2) duty follows the return, whatever form the return took.

Reading a s.142(1) questionnaire as the notice. It is a call for documents, not the notice that assumes jurisdiction to scrutinise. Look for a document that says s.143(2) on its face.

Settling first and reading the file later. s.270AA immunity on a 1961-Act order requires that no appeal is filed. For a 2025-Act order, s.440 and Form 161 carry the same condition plus an undertaking not to appeal (Notification 134/2026). The Dispute Resolution Committee, now s.379 (ex-s.245MA), requires a pending appeal to be withdrawn once the application is admitted, and its decision is final (reported). Each route trades away the appeal in which a void order would be quashed outright. Immunity buys peace on penalty. It is a poor trade for an order that should not exist.

Assuming the ground is only for the first appeal. The ITAT and the High Court in this case dealt with it as a jurisdictional point, and commentary reads the ruling as available in pending appeals. Whether a particular tribunal admits it as an additional ground depends on that record, so raise it at the earliest stage you can.

What to do

  1. Pull every reassessment file the office holds for the years under the 1961 Act, and list for each the s.148 notice date, the return or letter filed in response, and every notice issued afterwards.
  2. Look for a notice issued under s.143(2) after that return, with its date and mode of service. A s.142(1) questionnaire does not count.
  3. Where none exists and an order has been passed, raise the ground in the appeal, or as an additional ground if the appeal is already filed, citing 2026 INSC 1171.
  4. Where the proceeding is still open, put the objection on record in writing now.
  5. Before advising s.270AA immunity or a DRC application on any reassessment order this season, finish steps 1 and 2 first.

The tool

There is no tool with this piece, on purpose. I have built a resolver that weighs s.270AA immunity against an appeal on a reassessment order. It is not live, and it does not yet ask whether the order had jurisdiction in the first place. Until it does, it could recommend immunity on an order this ruling would void. When it is published with that check, I will link it here. The check in steps 1 and 2 needs nothing but the file.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court — PCIT, Bhubaneswar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd, 2026 INSC 1171 (28 October 2026), as reported by Verdictum — https://www.verdictum.in/supreme-court/principal-commissioner-of-income-tax-bhubaneshwar-v-orissa-mining-corporation-ltd-2026-insc-1171-1624764
  2. LiveLaw — Reassessment void without s.143(2) notice; s.292BB cannot cure complete absence of notice (30 October 2026) — https://www.livelaw.in/tax-cases/supreme-court-reassessment-void-section292bb-cannot-cure-complete-non-absence-notice-556609
  3. TaxGuru — reassessment notices issued from 1 April 2026 and the s.536 saving — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/income-tax-reassessment-pending-proceedings-new-notices-from-1st-april-2026.html
  4. TheTaxCorp — reassessment under the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the s.279–s.281 mapping) — https://thetaxcorp.in/article/reassessment-under-income-tax-act-2025-decoding-the-new-framework-transition
  5. A2Z Taxcorp — revised Form 161 for waiver under s.440 (Notification 134/2026) — https://a2ztaxcorp.net/cbdt-notifies-revised-income-tax-form-no-161-for-waiver-of-penalty-under-section-440-of-income-tax-act-2025-prescribes-additional-tax-of-100-and-120/
  6. Patron Accounting — the Dispute Resolution Committee under s.379 — https://www.patronaccounting.com/blog/dispute-resolution-committee-drc-rules-2026-eligibility-application-section-379

Share line (for WhatsApp / LinkedIn — Karan pastes it once the article is live)

SC, 28 Oct 2026 (Orissa Mining): no s.143(2) notice after the s.148 return = reassessment void; s.292BB and participation don't cure it. Check the file before taking s.270AA immunity.