Platform sellers: why AIS, GST TCS and your books never agree
An e-commerce platform deducts income tax on the gross order value, collects GST on the net value of taxable supplies after returns, and pays you net of commission and fees, so the figure in your
Summary
An e-commerce platform deducts income tax on the gross order value, collects GST on the net value of taxable supplies after returns, and pays you net of commission and fees, so the figure in your AIS, the TCS credit on the GST portal and the turnover in your books are three different numbers and none of them is wrong. When the notice comes, the job is not to make them agree but to show, rupee by rupee, why they differ.
The situation
A seller on a marketplace opens his Annual Information Statement and finds platform sales of ₹48.6 lakh. His books say ₹37.9 lakh. The GST TCS credited to him that year implies ₹37.9 lakh too, which only makes it stranger. On the Amazon seller forum the complaint reads, almost word for word, that the TCS in GST and the TDS in 26AS are not the same. The platform's support desk answers a different question.
The same thing happens to every restaurant on a food-delivery app, in a sharper form. The first thing that arrives is an intimation adjusting income, or an e-proceedings notice asking him to explain the difference.
The explanation is structural, and it is the same every time.
The rule
Income tax: deducted on the gross. For payments up to 31 March 2026 the platform deducted under section 194-O of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The rate was 1% until 30 September 2024 and 0.1% from 1 October 2024. From 1 April 2026 the same deduction sits in section 393(1), Table Sl. No. 8(v) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the old section 194-O), still at 0.1% of the gross amount of sales or services. An individual or HUF seller whose sales through that platform stay within ₹5,00,000 in the year, and who has given PAN or Aadhaar, suffers no deduction.
What is inside "gross" comes from CBDT's guidelines under section 194-O (Circular 17/2020 of 29 September 2020). Packing, shipping and convenience charges separately charged to the buyer are part of the gross. The platform's commission and fees are not taken out of it. Where GST is shown separately on the invoice and tax is deducted at the time of credit, the GST is excluded; where the deduction happens on payment, it is on the whole amount including GST.
GST: collected on the net. Under section 52 of the CGST Act the operator collects tax at source on the net value of taxable supplies, at 0.5% from 10 July 2024 (Notification 15/2024-Central Tax; 1% before that). The Explanation to section 52(1) defines the base as taxable supplies made through the operator, other than services notified under section 9(5), reduced by supplies returned during the month. The operator files GSTR-8 by the 10th of the next month, and the seller accepts the amount under "TDS and TCS Credit Received", after which it sits in his electronic cash ledger.
The restaurant case. Restaurant service through an e-commerce operator is notified under section 9(5) from 1 January 2022: the operator pays the 5% GST itself. Those supplies are therefore outside the section 52 base, and the GST TCS on them is nil by law, while the income-tax deduction continues on the gross order value.
| The figure | Where you see it | Base | Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platform sales in AIS / 26AS | AIS, e-commerce head | Gross order value, including shipping and convenience charges; GST inside or outside depending on when the platform deducts | 0.1% (1% up to 30 Sep 2024) |
| GST TCS credit | GST portal, "TDS and TCS Credit Received"; the operator's GSTR-8 | Net taxable supplies after returns; section 9(5) supplies excluded | 0.5% (1% up to 9 Jul 2024) |
| Turnover in the books | Your P&L | Often the settlement amount, after commission, fees and returns | — |
Where people go wrong
Grossing up the TDS at 1%. Several explainers still print 1%. A seller who divides his AIS deduction by 1% gets a turnover a tenth of the truth, and a notice reply built on that number collapses. For any period after 30 September 2024 the rate is 0.1%.
Expecting the GST TCS to match the AIS. It never will. Returns come off the GST base in the month they happen; they do not come off the income-tax gross. Shipping charges sit in one base and not necessarily in the other. The useful check runs the other way: divide the TCS by 0.5% and the result should sit close to the books, not to the AIS.
A restaurant looking for its TCS. There is none to find on the restaurant supplies. A food-app partner who reads nil TCS as "the platform forgot" is reading the statute as a mistake.
One rate across a changed year. FY 2024-25 has a GST rate change on 10 July 2024 and an income-tax rate change on 1 October 2024. A single blended rate across either date produces a figure that looks precise and is not.
Two platforms, one line. The AIS e-commerce line can reportedly arrive aggregated across platforms, so the figure you are reconciling may not be one platform's at all. Check the payer details before you start.
Absorbing the residual. After the named items, whatever is left is either an item you have not found yet (orders in March settled in April, a cancelled order whose deduction was not reversed) or an error. Writing it off as "miscellaneous" is the one thing the officer will ask about.
Citing the new section for an old year. A reply for FY 2025-26 cites section 194-O. Section 393 applies to amounts from 1 April 2026. No CBDT circular on section 393(1) Sl. 8(v) had appeared as at 14 September 2026, so the guidance on what "gross" includes is still the 1961-Act circular, and the reply should say so.
What to do
- Take four figures for the same period: the AIS e-commerce figure, the gross order value and commission-and-fees from one settlement report, the returns, and the GST TCS credited on the portal.
- Check the rate and the section against the dates: 1% or 0.1% for income tax around 1 October 2024, 1% or 0.5% for GST around 10 July 2024, section 194-O or section 393 around 1 April 2026.
- Bridge from the AIS gross down to the booked turnover, naming each item: commission and fees, returns, shipping and convenience charges, GST where it was inside the gross, and timing.
- Run the GST cross-check separately (TCS ÷ 0.5% against the books) and never mix the two tax heads in one reconciliation.
- Attach the bridge to the reply with the provisions stated, keep the settlement report and the AIS page it came from, and leave any residual visible.
The tool
I kept rebuilding this bridge for sellers on a blank sheet, so I built a page that prints it. You type five numbers (the gross the platform reported, your booked turnover, commission and fees, returns, and the GST TCS), answer whether GST was inside the reported gross, and it names each rupee of the gap, runs the GST cross-check as a separate calculation, switches to the nil-TCS explanation for a restaurant, refuses to use one GST rate across 10 July 2024, and prints a one-page reconciliation with an optional annexure of the provisions for the officer. It does not read a settlement report (formats drift, and a silently wrong parser is worse than none), it does not decide whether your books are right, a residual stays a residual, and it does not draft the reply. Its printed annexure cites section 393(1) Sl. 8(v), which is right from 1 April 2026; for FY 2025-26 or earlier, correct that line to section 194-O. Nothing you type leaves your browser. Use it free, and verify with your CA.
Sources
- CBIC — section 52, CGST Act, 2017 (the Explanation to section 52(1)) — https://taxinformation.cbic.gov.in/content/html/tax_repository/gst/acts/2017_CGST_act/active/chapter10/section52_v1.00.html
- TDSMAN — TDS on e-commerce transactions, section 393(1) (section 194-O) (July 2026) — https://blog.tdsman.com/2026/07/tds-on-e-commerce-transactions-section-3931-194o/
- KPMG India — Flash News on CBDT's guidelines under section 194-O (Circular 17/2020) — https://www.in.kpmg.com/taxflashnews/KPMG-Flash-News-CBDT-guidelines-for-the-deduction-of-TDS-under-Section-194-O-of-the-Act.pdf
- BDO India — additional guidelines on section 194-O — https://www.bdo.in/en-gb/insights/alerts-updates/cbdt-issues-additional-guidelines-on-tds-by-e-commerce-operators-under-section-194-o-of-the-it-act
- TaxGuru — Notification 15/2024-Central Tax, TCS rate reduced — https://taxguru.in/goods-and-service-tax/cgst-e-commerce-operator-tcs-collection-rate-reduced-0-25-percent.html
- Patron Accounting — section 52 TCS and the credit-received path — https://www.patronaccounting.com/blog/tcs-section-52-ecommerce-gst-explained
- Terra Insight — Zomato restaurant settlement reconciliation — https://www.terra-insight.com/insights/zomato-restaurant-settlement-reconciliation/
- Amazon Seller Central forum — the TCS / 26AS mismatch thread — https://sellercentral.amazon.in/seller-forums/discussions/t/01950e77-ed83-45ce-9aa7-48808e273467