Got the FAST-DS e-mail? It is an advisory, and one asset can owe two prices

The FAST-DS e-mails the income-tax department has been sending since late September are advisories, not notices: nothing is payable because of the e-mail, and the only date in play is the scheme's
Summary
The FAST-DS e-mails the income-tax department has been sending since late September are advisories, not notices: nothing is payable because of the e-mail, and the only date in play is the scheme's own close on 31 December 2026. If the foreign asset was bought with taxed money but some income from it was never taxed, the asset and the income are priced separately: a flat ₹1,00,000 for the asset, and 30% plus an equal amount on the untaxed income alone.
The situation
On 30 October a practitioner asked on CAclubindia about a client who received the e-mail. The client got RSUs in FY 2023-24, earned a ₹35,000 foreign dividend that year, reported neither, and has reported both in Schedule FA from FY 2024-25 onward. The question was whether the client now owes "₹1 lakh penalty and 60% tax".
The first reply advised reading "the section cited in the notice" and arguing bona fide intent. That answers a question nobody has asked yet. The e-mail cites no section that demands anything, and the client's choice is not how to defend himself but which route to declare under, if any, before 31 December.
The rule
What the e-mail is. CBDT's system-generated e-mails on foreign assets went out from about 25 September 2026, titled as an advisory on voluntary compliance regarding foreign assets under FAST-DS 2026. They point the recipient to AIS → Foreign Assets Information and to the declaration window, and are described as "not legal notices" (TaxGuru, 29 September 2026, reported; the e-mail text was not read first-party). CBDT's own office memorandum of 17 July 2026 calls the AIS foreign-asset display "facilitative in nature". Nothing is payable until a declaration is filed or an assessment is made.
What the scheme charges. The Foreign Assets of Small Taxpayers Disclosure Scheme, 2026 (Finance Act, 2026, Chapter IV; Rules by Notification 114/2026) runs to 31 December 2026, with values at 31 March 2026:
| What is undisclosed | Category | Cap | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| An asset whose source is explained and was taxed (or acquired while non-resident) | B | ₹5 crore of asset value | Flat ₹1,00,000 |
| An asset whose source is unexplained or untaxed, and any foreign income never offered to tax | A | ₹1 crore, asset value plus that income together | 30% tax plus an equal amount — about 60% |
The point the forum thread turns on: the categories are applied to the asset and to the income separately. Income never offered to tax is Category A whatever route its asset takes, so one asset can sit in both at once.
The forum's facts, priced. The RSUs were perquisites taxed through salary, so the holding was bought with taxed money: Category B, ₹1,00,000. The ₹35,000 dividend of FY 2023-24 was never taxed: Category A on the income, 30% plus an equal amount on ₹35,000, about ₹21,000. Not 60% of the shares. Total, on one reading of the fee, about ₹1,21,000.
Where people go wrong
Treating the e-mail as a demand. It is not a notice and starts no limitation clock of its own. It is also a template that fraudsters copy: a phishing mail with CBDT branding, a 72-hour deadline and no DIN has circulated since 3 September 2026 (TaxGuru, 3 September). The e-mail's own links pass through a third-party tracking domain. Do not click; log in to the portal yourself. Check any income-tax message with the e-filing portal's Authenticate Notice/Order facility, and an AIS communication with "Authenticate Insight DIN" on the AIS home page (CBDT OM of 17 July 2026).
Thinking the later years cure the earlier one. Reporting the asset in Schedule FA from FY 2024-25 does nothing for FY 2023-24. The year that was missed is the year that is undisclosed.
Pricing the whole asset at 60%. Only the untaxed part goes to Category A. In the forum case the shares were funded from taxed salary; it is the dividend that was never taxed.
Reaching for an updated return instead. An updated return (ITR-U) under s.139(8A) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 — the Act that still governs FY 2023-24; the 2025 Act's provision is s.263(6) — can bring the dividend to tax. Two cautions. First, s.139(8A) bars an updated return where information for the year has been received under a s.90/90A agreement and communicated to the taxpayer. Whether an AIS line or this e-mail is that communication has not been settled by any authority I could find. Second, a practitioner reading is that ITR-U cures the income-tax default but not the Black Money Act, 2015 penalty for the Schedule FA omission (TaxGuru, 29 September 2026). A FAST-DS declaration carries immunity under that Act; ITR-U does not.
Assuming FAST-DS settles FEMA. It does not. An unreported foreign holding may need its own FEMA review.
Filing the wrong return type for years. The forum client filed ITR-1. ITR-1 has no Schedule FA, and a resident holding any foreign asset is not eligible to use it. That is how the gap began, and it is worth fixing for the current year before the next return is due.
What to do
- Verify the message on the portal (Authenticate Notice/Order, or Authenticate Insight DIN in AIS), never through the e-mail's links.
- List every foreign asset and every year it was held while resident, and mark which years' returns carried it in Schedule FA.
- For each unreported year, split the asset from its income: was the money that bought it taxed, and was the income it produced offered to tax that year?
- Price the asset under Category B and the untaxed income under Category A, check both caps, and compare that with the updated-return route only after reading the s.139(8A) bar against your own facts.
- File Form 1 well inside December if the declaration is the route; the window closes on 31 December 2026.
The tool
I kept re-doing the split in step 3 by hand, so the resolver I built for FAST-DS does it per asset. You enter each asset's class and value at 31 March 2026 (in its own currency, with the rate you supply), the income from it that was never offered to tax, and two questions on Schedule FA and source. It tells you the category for the asset and for its income separately, tests both caps on what each is measured on, and prices the declaration, as a range where more than one Category B asset makes the flat fee ambiguous. The version live since today counts every rupee of untaxed income you type. An earlier hidden default could drop it. It does not read the e-mail, decide whether the s.139(8A) bar applies to you, or file anything. It stores nothing.
Open the fast ds route check page
If you are not yet sure the AIS line is a real gap, start one step earlier with the AEOI line triage: Open the aeoi line triage page
Sources
- CBDT OM F.No. 414(B)/21/2023-IT(Inv.VI)/64, 17 July 2026, note on CRS data in AIS — https://www.incometax.gov.in/iec/foportal/sites/default/files/2026-07/OM_17.07.2026_Hosting%20of%20Note%20on%20CRS%20in%20AIS.pdf
- Income-tax Act, 1961, s.139(8A) third proviso (updated return bars) — as enacted; see TaxGuru's FAQ reproduction — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/section-139-8a-updated-return-itr-u-faqs.html
- TaxGuru — Received the FAST-DS e-mail? Check AIS before 31 December 2026 (29 September 2026) — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/received-fast-ds-email-foreign-assets-check-ais-31-december-2026.html
- TaxGuru — fake income-tax penalty e-mail with a 72-hour deadline (3 September 2026) — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/fake-income-tax-penalty-email-72-hour-deadline-scam.html
- CAclubindia forum — FAST DS 2026 Mail: RSU Shares & Dividend Tax Query (30 October – 2 November 2026) — https://www.caclubindia.com/forum/fast-ds-2026-mail-query-616215.asp
- My earlier piece with the four-question test and the valuation table — the related note
Share line (for WhatsApp / LinkedIn — Karan pastes it once the article is live)
The FAST-DS e-mail is an advisory, not a notice. Taxed RSUs = ₹1 lakh flat; untaxed dividend = ~60% of the dividend only, not the shares. Window shuts 31 Dec: Open the fast ds route check page