A doctor's receipts crossed ₹50 lakh: audit, or still section 58?
From tax year 2026-27, a doctor on the presumptive scheme in section 58 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the old 44ADA) keeps it up to ₹75 lakh of receipts if cash stays within 5%, and section 63 (the
Summary
From tax year 2026-27, a doctor on the presumptive scheme in section 58 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the old 44ADA) keeps it up to ₹75 lakh of receipts if cash stays within 5%, and section 63 (the old 44AB) does not apply to anyone who declares profit under section 58(2), so a doctor at ₹62 lakh who declares half his receipts needs no tax audit. What decides it is the cash share and the dispensing counter, both of which can still be managed with six months of the year left.
The situation
A physician's fee receipts will be about ₹62 lakh this year. Last year he was under ₹50 lakh and filed ITR-4. His CA's instinct, formed under the 1961 Act, is that crossing ₹50 lakh means books and an audit. The flowcharts in circulation still say 44ADA and 44AB. The three presumptive sections have since been merged into one table, and the audit section has been rewritten.
He also has a dispensing counter in the same clinic, on the same PAN, taking about ₹22 lakh a year. The first question most people ask is whether ₹62 lakh plus ₹22 lakh is over ₹75 lakh. That is the wrong sum.
The rule
Section 58 is one table in place of the old ss.44AD, 44ADA and 44AE. A medical practitioner carries on a specified profession under s.62(4) (the old s.44AA(1)), so his entry is Sl. No. 3:
| Sl. No. 3 — specified profession (ex-44ADA) | Sl. No. 1 — business (ex-44AD) | |
|---|---|---|
| Ceiling | Gross receipts up to ₹50 lakh, or ₹75 lakh where cash receipts are within 5% | Turnover up to ₹2 crore, or ₹3 crore where cash receipts are within 5% |
| Deemed income | 50% of gross receipts, or actual if higher | 6% of banked receipts plus 8% of the rest, or actual if higher |
| Five-year lock-in | None | Yes |
A cheque or draft that is not account payee counts as cash. The 5% test for a profession looks at receipts only.
The audit section now carves presumptive filers out. s.63 requires audit where business turnover exceeds ₹1 crore (₹10 crore where cash receipts and cash payments are each within 5%), where gross receipts of a profession exceed ₹50 lakh, or where profit declared is lower than the deemed amount. It then says it "shall not apply where profits and gains of business or profession, declared by the assessee are as per section 58(2) or 61(2)." The old s.44AB(b) had no such carve-out for 44ADA, and a professional between ₹50 lakh and ₹75 lakh was left arguing the point.
Two dates, two months apart, both under s.263(1) for tax year 2026-27:
| Position | Audit report | Return |
|---|---|---|
| Inside s.58, declaring 50% or more | none | 31 August 2027 (ITR-4) |
| Outside s.58, or declaring less | 30 September 2027 | 31 October 2027 |
s.58 is open to an individual, a HUF or a firm that is not an LLP.
Where people go wrong
Adding the counter to the fees. The ₹75 lakh ceiling is on gross receipts in profession. Takings from medicines or a diagnostic arm are not professional receipts. Add them and a doctor who is inside the scheme appears to be outside it. Test the two streams separately, and apply s.63's business threshold to the counter on its own.
Putting the counter on 6% and 8%. The eligible-assessee definition for the business entry excludes a person carrying on a specified profession. It mirrors s.44AD(6)(i), which on its face excludes the person, not the business. The dominant reading is that a doctor cannot use the presumptive business rate for a counter on the same PAN, so the counter goes on actual profits with books. The other reading treats the exclusion as aimed at the business and allows Sl. No. 1. Practitioner commentary calls it open, and no clarification has come. I would plan on the first reading.
Copying the five-year lock-in across. The lock-in belongs to the business entry. A professional can come in and out of Sl. No. 3 year by year, which is why this is a decision for this year only.
Ignoring ₹620. Cash of ₹3,10,000 on ₹62 lakh is exactly 5%, and the ceiling stays ₹75 lakh. Cash of ₹3,10,620 is over 5%, the ceiling drops to ₹50 lakh, the doctor is ₹12 lakh outside the scheme, and books and an audit follow. The test is "does not exceed", and it is worth doing in whole rupees.
Declaring 40% to be safe. Declaring less than the deemed 50% triggers books and an audit. Under the 1961 Act that bit only where total income exceeded the basic exemption. I could not find that condition in the s.63 wording, so assume the audit follows.
Applying all this to the year just ended. For the year to 31 March 2026, being audited this week, ss.44ADA, 44AA and 44AB still apply, and the audit point above was not settled there.
What to do
- Split the doctor's receipts into professional fees and everything else (medicines, tests, the counter), and keep them apart in every test.
- Work out cash as a share of professional receipts to date, and the cash he can still take this year before 5% is crossed.
- Tell the clinic in October, not March: bank the rest, and treat any bearer cheque as cash.
- Decide the counter on the restrictive reading: books from now, and an audit only if its own turnover crosses s.63's business threshold.
- Diarise the right pair of dates, 31 August 2027 or 30 September and 31 October 2027, based on where he actually lands.
The tool
Every October the same Excel sheet came out for doctor clients, and it always ended in the same argument about the counter. So I built a breaker. You enter five things: fee receipts, the cash in them, the counter's takings, whether the practice will declare less than half, and how it is held. One sentence tells you whether s.58 still holds, the cash headroom left in rupees, what happens to the counter on both readings (the restrictive one leads), and which two dates apply. It prints a one-page position note for the engagement file. It deliberately shows no tax figure at all. It does not cover the year to 31 March 2026, and it does not touch GST on the counter. It does not keep books, and it does not decide whether a medicine supplied during treatment is part of the profession. It stores nothing off your machine.
Sources
- Section 58, Income-tax Act, 2025 (Act mirror) — https://eztax.in/income-tax-act-2025/section-58
- Section 63, Income-tax Act, 2025 (Act mirror) — https://eztax.in/income-tax-act-2025/section-63
- TaxGuru — Tax audit under the Income-tax Act, 2025, with FAQs — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/provisions-related-tax-audit-income-tax-act-2025-faqs.html
- TaxGuru — Presumptive taxation under section 58 — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/presumptive-taxation-section-58-income-tax-act-2025.html
- TaxGuru — the three-section merge — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/presumptive-taxation-simplified-income-tax-act-2025-merges-44ad-44ada-44ae.html
- Karnani & Co — Presumptive taxation for professionals under the 2025 Act (s.62(4); no lock-in) — https://www.karnanica.com/presumptive-taxation-for-professionals/
- CAclubindia — Simultaneous use of s.44AD and s.44ADA — https://www.caclubindia.com/articles/simultaneous-use-of-sec-44ad-and-sec-44ada-38657.asp
- TaxGuru — Businesses and professions that cannot opt for 44AD — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/list-businesses-professions-opt-presumptive-taxation-scheme-covered-u-s-44ad.html
- TaxGuru — AY 2026-27 ITR due dates after the Finance Act, 2026 — https://taxguru.in/income-tax/ay-2026-27-itr-due-dates-finance-act-2026.html